Us Vs. Them, by N. Gordon Cosby

हम और वे की सोच
एन. गॉर्डन कॉस्बी

एक महान नेता के भीतर कभी भी ‘हम और वे की सोच’ नहीं होती। वह हर किसी के पक्ष में होता है। किसी एक विचारधारा या समुदाय के पक्ष में होने का मतलब कभी भी दूसरे के खिलाफ होना नहीं होता। सत्ता या शक्ति से वंचित लोगों के पक्ष में होने का अर्थ निश्चित रूप से शक्तिशाली लोगों के खिलाफ होना नहीं है।

टकराव या संघर्ष की व्यक्तिगत स्थितियों में संकीर्णता अक्सर देखने को मिलती है। हम अपने दो दोस्तों की कहानी सुनते हैं। उनमें से एक पीड़ित नजर आता है। एक सही और दूसरा गलत प्रतीत होता है, और हम आसानी से उस “खलनायक” के प्रति अपनी सहानुभूति वापस ले लेते हैं।

मान लेते हैं कि स्थिति का हमारा आकलन बिल्कुल सही है, हालांकि इस पर बड़ा सवाल उठाया जा सकता है। इस पल का जो खलनायक है, वह पिछले किसी पल का पीड़ित रहा है। चूंकि मैं गहराई से किसी एक के पक्ष में हूँ, तो मुझे दूसरे के खिलाफ क्यों होना चाहिए? मैं दोनों के ही पक्ष में गहराई से क्यों नहीं खड़ा हो सकता? अगर मैं दूसरे की तुलना में किसी एक का पक्ष लेने के अपने रवैये पर पूरी तरह अड़ियल हूँ, तो मैं अन्य लोगों के दृष्टिकोण की स्वतंत्रता को कम कर रहा हूँ। ऐसा करके मैं नेतृत्व करने की अपनी क्षमता को सीमित कर रहा हूँ।

मैं अपने जीवन के उद्देश्य में और उस व्यवस्था में अंतिम अर्थ खोज सकता हूँ जिसका मैं एक हिस्सा हूँ—और इसके साथ ही, मैं उस संपूर्णता के अन्य पहलुओं को भी बेहतर बना सकता हूँ जिससे मैं जुड़ा हूँ। मैं संपूर्णता का हिस्सा बनकर और उस संपूर्णता को समृद्ध करके कभी भी उस विशेष कार्य या समूह को नुकसान नहीं पहुँचाऊँगा जिसके लिए मुझे चुना गया है। मुझे अपने उस विशेष कार्य के लिए जिस भी चीज़ की आवश्यकता है, वह हमेशा मेरे पास वापस लौटकर आएगी यदि मैं स्वयं को उस संपूर्णता को समर्पित कर देता हूँ।

हमें ऐसा कुछ भी नहीं करना चाहिए जो किसी भी तरह से दूसरे व्यक्ति की गरिमा, महत्ता या मानवीय मूल्य को कम करे।

चिंतन के लिए बीज प्रश्न:

आप इस विचार के बारे में क्या सोचते हैं कि “इस पल का खलनायक पिछले किसी पल का पीड़ित रहा है” — यानी किसी के गलत काम को देखना वास्तव में अपनी सहानुभूति को वापस लेने के बजाय, हमारी करुणा के दायरे को और बढ़ाने का एक आमंत्रण हो सकता है?
क्या आप अपने जीवन की कोई ऐसी व्यक्तिगत कहानी साझा कर सकते हैं जब आपने किसी संघर्ष या विवाद में स्वयं को दोनों पक्षों के लिए जगह और सहानुभूति बनाते हुए पाया हो?
जब आपके भीतर की हर भावना किसी को सही या गलत, नायक या खलनायक के रूप में देखना चाहती है, तब ऐसी स्थिति में आपको उस परिस्थिति की समग्रता से जुड़े रहने में कौन-सी चीज़ मदद करती है?

Excerpt from N. Gordon Cosby's book, By Grace Transformed.

Seed Questions for Reflection

What do you make of the idea that "the villain of this moment is the victim of an earlier moment" - that seeing someone's wrongdoing might actually be an invitation to widen our compassion rather than withdraw it? Can you share a personal story of a time when you found yourself holding space for both sides in a conflict? What helps you stay connected to the wholeness of a situation when everything in you wants to label someone as right or wrong, hero or villain?

Moved by this reading? Join a live Awakin Circle to discuss in community.

Join this week

More ways to connect

Join a Metta Circle

Practice loving-kindness meditation together

Explore peer-learning pods

Small groups diving deeper into shared themes

Start your own local circle

One living room, one intention — we'll help

Add Your Reflection

12 Past Reflections

Tatvi

Jun 16, 2026

This reflection reminded me of a difficult situation between two roommates who were both my best friends individually. One of them was repeatedly absent from college because of health issues and other personal struggles. As a result, teachers became upset, and sometimes I was also scolded because I was associated with her. When she came to me and shared how hurt she felt, I initially focused on the problems her absence was creating for everyone else. It seemed obvious who was right and who was wrong. However, after listening to her, I realized that she was carrying a lot of pain that many of us did not fully understand. She felt judged, isolated, and unsupported at a time when she was already struggling physically and emotionally. At the same time, I could also understand the frustration of the other friend and the teachers. They were concerned about attendance, responsibilities, and the impact her absence was having on others. Both sides were hurting in different ways. Readin... View full comment

Anand

Jun 16, 2026

When we see someone playing a villian in the sense that he is exploiting best way is to keep empathy from a safe distance

Jun 16, 2026

I couldn't agree more. This perspective requires both deep self-knowledge and mindful awareness of our reactions. It requires empathy for the experience of being human and "skillful" means in addressing issues and conflict. It requires the ability to think critically and at times to carefully analyze. I am very pleased that this perspective is being supported and brought forth. Creating enemies, holding ill will, blaming without understanding; all are the building blocks of disharmony and endless conflict. Though there are times when we must act to protect, we do not need to do so with hate. Thank you.

Jayendra Shah

Jun 15, 2026

I 100% agree with the notion of "the villain of this moment is the victim of an earlier moment". One tends to behave or act based on his or her previous experiences and exposures.
When we are born, we all are neutral blank human being. We all turn out to be who we are now is based on family where we are born, area or town or country we are born, school where we learned, friends we had, community in which we grew, and so many factors. Sometimes we get tough with or dislike certain people (so called villains) based on social and other norms, but instead we need to be open hearted and compassionate, realising that if we would have been brought up in those circumstances, we would not have been much different from them. We need to understand why this person is behaving like this.

Shivani Singhal

Jun 15, 2026

This is so powerful. And it's left me curious about how this is held in balance with the need to take decisions to remove someone from a situation, or to remove oneself from a situation, because of a lack of safety or similar. How do we balance the practicalities and needs of a group and a team, with a deep compassion and acknowledgement of the wholeness of each individual and each situation.

I'm tussling with this at work right now - and whilst I have compassion and empathy (maybe not as much as I would hope to have) with some of the folks in question, it's making it harder for me to make some important decisions. Would love any wisdom on this from others who've walked this path.

David Doane, author of A Psychotherapist's View of Reality

Jun 15, 2026

I agree that the villain of this moment is the victim of an earlier moment. I agree that it's important to widen our compassion. For me that means to appreciate that we are systems more than we are individuals. In my career I made an effort to be of help to many couples. When there is conflict, we blame, don't see our part in the problem, don't take responsibility, and play pin the tail on the donkey. We see one as villain and the other as victim rather than look at how two created the situation. "Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee agreed to have a battle" as said in Through the Looking Glass. We do the same game of blaming and divisiveness at the level of national politics as we do at the level of personal relationships. When I remember that we are one whole system that is basic and much bigger than our divisiveness, that helps me keep in check my wanting to label 'us' as right and good and 'them' as wrong or bad.

Dielle Hamilton

Jun 13, 2026

I have not taken much time with this new topic, but I have a friend who does an NPR podcast called Us & Them. Links aren't allowed here, but you can easily find it. It emanates from West Virginia Public Broadcasting and Peabody Award-winning public radio producer Trey Kay, who listens to people on both sides of the divide & tells stories from the fault lines that separate Americans.

I have had many conversations about how I find the phrase unhelpful & separating, choosing to try to heal the divide that seems ever-widening rather than accentuate the fault lines. I will find the time to return here as I certainly appreciate the seed question & invite you to check out my friend's podcast.

Allie Middleton

Jun 12, 2026

As a digital immigrant, I sometimes feel the sting of not being able to follow directions that others seem to navigate with ease. In those moments, it is easy to feel left behind.

Yet I am learning to see this with greater gentleness. I come from a different landscape of learning, one shaped by books, conversations, handwritten notes, and lived experience. The digital world asks for new forms of attention and fluency.

Rather than a deficit, I am beginning to see this as an invitation—to remain humble, curious, and willing to learn. It has also deepened my appreciation for patience and for the kindness of those who help bridge the gap between different generations of ways of knowing.

Jun 12, 2026

This reminds me of my dream that I was Trumps caretaker! I was at first appalled but then remembered I had read the NYT story about his father and how he had accounts/ businesses in baby Trumps name. It's not his fault he is who he is or the others who desire power and greed over human health and connection. I don't know how to fix it except lead by example. After an angry woman on the phone cussed and fussed about me honking my horn to make sure she was paying attention enough not to hit my car. I left a note saying "I apologize, you needed a hug not a honk". She looked like family and we all have been in a heightened emotional state on the go.

Shaktima

Jun 11, 2026

"The great leader never feels it is us versus them. He or she is for everybody. To be for one interest group is never to be against another. To be for those without power is surely not to be against those with power."

In a world so hyper-focused on politics, it would do us all good to apply this to ourselves collectively. Rather than should-ing on whatever nonsense we are watching in the arena and whichever person holds the leader title, if we truly belived this AND honestly walked this, the circus of hatred that current day politics thrive one could not be sustained.

Janet Heartson

Jun 11, 2026

That saying hurt people hurt people is accurate. As a counselor, I address these things often. Let's look underneath that action, what triggers or wounds were you reacting from? How can you choose differently next time. It's compassion from me and learning compassion for themselves so they can learn and start anew.

Jagdish P Dave

Jun 11, 2026

Reality or Truth is One. It is not Two. Reading this passage authored by N. Gordan Cosby reminds me of an ancient saying written in Sanskrit. Ekam Satyam bahudha vadanti. Truth is One expressed by sages in different ways. Sadly some of us may not perceive the Reality as One. Such a way of perceiving the Truth and not following it has caused divisiveness and battles and wars. We see such battles and wars between two nations, USA and Iran causing destruction on both sides. Sadly we see such divisiveness in families, communities and nations. How many battles and wars have been created and how much damage and destruction has been created. UNO has been created to unite nations of the world for peace. Sadly the UNO has not been able to achieve it. It is time to wake up. It is time to join heads, hands and hearts and learn to relate to each other as brothers and sisters. A couple of years ago I had visited Auroville, a relatively small town in the southern part of India. I was happily s... View full comment