Email not displaying correctly? View it in your browser.
InnerNet Weekly: Inspirations from

The Difference Between Education and Training
by Rachel Naomi Remen

[Listen to Audio!]

For me, the process of education is intimately related to the process of healing. The root word of education -- educare -- means to lead forth a hidden wholeness in another person. A genuine education fosters self-knowledge, self-trust, creativity and the full expression of one’s unique identity. It gives people the courage to be more. Yet over the years so many health professionals have told me that they feel personally wounded by their experience of professional school and profoundly diminished by it. This was my experience as well.

It has made me wonder. Perhaps what we have all experienced is not an education at all but a training, which is something quite different. Certainly in medicine the training dimension of schooling has become more and more central and assumed a greater importance as the many techniques of the scientific approach have been developed. The goal of a training is competence and replicability. Uniqueness is often discouraged and may even be viewed as dangerous.

A training is all about the right way and the wrong way to do everything. In a training your own way of doing something can often become irrelevant. In such a milieu students often experience their learning as a constant struggle to be good enough. Training creates a culture of relentless evaluation and judgment. In response students try to become someone different than who they are.

At the end of the Healer’s Art teachings, the students stand in a large circle, silently review their memories of the course and identify the most important thing that they learned or remembered during the course. They then turn this insight into an affirmation: a little phrase which begins in one of three ways: I am ... I can ... or I will. One at a time, the students go around the circle each saying their phrase out loud. This year will be the 24th year that I have taught the course at my medical school. The most common thing that students say in this sharing is a simple three-word phase: I AM ENOUGH. Year after year it is the same phrase I myself say as well. It is the beginning of everything.

In Medicine, training is essential to technical competence. The real question is, is training good enough?

My dream of medicine was not to become competent. My dream was to become a friend to life. It was that dream that enabled me to endure the relentless pursuit of competency required of me. But competence did not fulfill me then and could not have fulfilled me for my medical lifetime. Only a dream can do that.

Share the Wisdom:  
Email   Twitter   FaceBook

Latest Community Insights New!
The Difference Between Education and Training
How do you relate to the difference between education and training? Can you share an experience where this difference became clear to you? What is the dream that helps you endure a relentless pursuit of competency?
Jagdish P Dave wrote:  During my long term as a learner, more than 30 years as a school learner- and the rest 60 years of out of school informal and life learner and as an educator, I have come to realize t...
Kristin Pedemonti wrote: As a Storyteller who facilitates workshops I resonate very much with this post. The difference between how you describe education and training came clear to me in Belize where I coordinated a volunte...
Jyoti wrote: The purpose of education is to let you discover your own heart's drumbeat so you can march to it. Sadly, like the healthcare system, the education system too has stifled individual creativity in favo...
Share/Read Reflections >>

      Awakin Wednesdays:
Many years ago, a couple friends got together to sit in silence for an hour, and share personal aha-moments. That birthed this newsletter, and later became "Wednesdays", which now ripple out to living rooms around the world. To join, RSVP online.

RSVP For Wednesday

Some Good News
•  The Relationship Between Self-Compassion & Procrastination
•  Slow Medicine: An Interview With Victoria Sweet
•  1000 Cranes For 1000 Strangers

Video of the Week
•  They Call Me "Clean-Up"

Kindness Stories
•  A Small Act of Kindness Makes it all Worthwhile
•  30 Acts of Kindness in 30 Days Challenge!
•  Fly On the Wall-Wannabe

Global call with KindSpring Challenge!
Join us for a conference call this Saturday, with a global group of ServiceSpace friends and our insightful guest speaker. Join the Forest Call >>

Back in 1997, one person started sending this simple "meditation reminder" to a few friends. Soon after, "Wednesdays" started, ServiceSpace blossomed, and the humble experiments of service took a life of its own. If you'd like to start an Awakin gathering in your area, we'd be happy to help you get started.

Forward to a Friend
InnerNet Weekly is an email service that delivers a little bit of wisdom to 87,859 subscribers each week. We never spam nor do we host any advertising. Archives, from the last 14+ years, are freely available online.

You can unsubscribe anytime, within seconds.

A Gift Economy offering of (2012)